♦The Article – Taken from CNN.com
Teen Christians campaign against pop culture
(CNN) — At one point in Jared Hutchins’ young life, the Beatles were a big problem.
“I had to stop listening to them for a while,” said Hutchins, who lives in Cumming, Georgia, and plays the piano, guitar and harmonica. He said the group’s world view “had a negative effect on me,” and made him irritable and angry.
“God owns my life, not the Beatles,” he said simply. Although Hutchins said he enjoys a wide range of music — from Pink Floyd and Arcade Fire to Christian bands such as Hillsong United — he said he has to be careful of what music he listens to, for the same reason he temporarily turned off the Beatles.
Hutchins, a 16-year-old graced with poise and thoughtfulness, is one of many teenagers who say that some part of popular culture, with its ubiquitous references to sex, drugs and violence, has harmed him.
Last year, Hutchins and his Christian youth group attended an Acquire the Fire rally in Atlanta, Georgia, he said. Acquire the Fire — regional rallies held across the country — and BattleCry — the larger rallies held this year in only three cities — are the products of the evangelical Christian organization Teen Mania.
One part concert, one part Christian revival, the rallies seek to “stage a reverse revolution” against secular popular culture. They have the pull of headlining rock concerts, drawing thousands of people regardless of the region of the country, the month of year or the day of the week. The audiences are nearly always predominantly teenagers and young adults.
From 2006 to 2007, a total of 127,830 people attended the 34 Acquire the Fire rallies, and 71,414 people attended the three BattleCry events held in San Francisco, California; Detroit, Michigan; and Bristow, Virginia, according to Teen Mania.
For Hutchins, who said he struggled in his early adolescence to fit in and be cool before having a personal experience with God about four years ago, the organization’s message is exactly right.
“We don’t have to be branded by the culture, we are branded by God,” he said. “Be who God created you to be.”
But the glossy, glamorous appeal of popular culture too often obscures that path to God, Teen Mania followers say.
And so, Ron Luce, the 46-year-old founder of the organization, has waged a modern-day crusade against “purveyors of popular culture,” whom he has condemned as “the enemy.” More than two decades old, Teen Mania estimates it has reached more than 2 million teens with its message “of living completely for Christ.”
The organization is sprawling. In addition to its live stadium rallies, there are BattleCry shirts and hats, mobile screen savers, books and a television program. There are international mission trips — Hutchins attended one in Tijuana, Mexico, this summer. There is even a Teen Mania internship, a one-year program called the Honor Academy, based in Lindale, Texas.
In the live events, Luce couples the earnest appeal of a young father with a preacher’s ability to mobilize a crowd. He weaves disturbing statistics about teenagers amid his gospel.
Today’s teenagers are in crisis, he says.
“Kids are hurting,” he said. And of those who he feels inflict these moral wounds, Luce said, “We call them terrorists, virtue terrorists, that are destroying our kids.”
“They’re raping virgin teenage America on the sidewalk, and everybody’s walking by and acting like everything’s OK. And it’s just not OK.”
“We’re fighting for those who don’t know they have a voice, that are being manipulated by our pop culture indulging in things that, really, they’re not mature enough to be thinking about yet,” Luce told CNN. “Kids are hurting,” he said. And of those who he feels inflict these moral wounds, Luce said, “We call them terrorists, virtue terrorists, that are destroying our kids.”
“They’re raping virgin teenage America on the sidewalk, and everybody’s walking by and acting like everything’s OK. And it’s just not OK.”
To some, Luce’s rhetoric is off-putting, hateful and divisive. Opponents point to his views on homosexuality — not “in God’s plan” — and abortion — the “ending of a precious life” — and say Luce is imposing conservative values on vulnerable teenagers.
It is this criticism that Luce and his followers confronted head-on in March at BattleCry San Francisco.
There, in arguably the most liberal city in the United States, protesters, armed with megaphones and poster board signs, rallied against BattleCry on the steps of City Hall as the Christian teenagers circled and prayed in a demonstration of their own.
“Ron Luce is a liar!” one protester shouted. “Let me hear you say Christian fascist,” another yelled.
Luce and the youths, some as young as 11, also raised their voices.
“God, I ask that as we do this BattleCry, Lord, that you would reveal yourself to the teenagers, God, here, God,” Mindy Peterson, shouted. Peterson is a member of Teen Mania’s Honor Academy. Afterward, Peterson railed against what she said was the protesters’ mischaracterization of BattleCry.
“These people think that our war is against other people. They think that our war is against man. And our war isn’t. Our war’s against … the pain in teenagers’ hearts, like depression, alcoholism. Those things that — that are, like, tearing our teenagers apart,” she said.
While much milder in his terms, Hutchins agrees. “We’re a generation that is kind of troubled,” he said. Luce wants to “rescue the hearts of our generation,” he added.
And of the critics’ contention that the rallies, the organization, the message is neo-conservatism wrapped in Biblical verse? Hutchins smiles, nods patiently. “I don’t go because I have a political agenda,” he said, adding that his friends don’t, either.
“Mostly, what we’re concerned with is Jesus.”
♦The Arguement
Okay, so, I was really tempted just to write ‘lol, what?’ here, and be done with it, but as I re-read the article again, I found I had something to say.
These people, this ‘Teen Mania’ organization, is trying to fight a ‘war’ against an enemy that is indestructible. It’s invincibility is based in the fact that it isn’t real. Pop culture as the enemy? The mass media blazing about that sex, drugs, and rock and roll are cool, and the theoretical ‘raping of virgin teenage America’ or whatever the hell these people are talking about, it’s not real, and therefore it can’t be beaten.
What do you mean, it isn’t real? I know the question is in your head. The media, the super high status celebrities that impress on us that everything they do is cool, that it’s okay, whatever; this doesn’t change our internal inborn compass of right and wrong. These zealots, for lack of a better word, don’t seem to understand that even if they were to somehow totally destroy the depraved images and concepts coming across in ‘pop culture’, they would never destroy our inner demons, the things that are already inside of us that cause us to stray from whatever path it is we’re supposed to follow in the first place. Man is, in its creation, a flawed being. All pop culture is doing is giving matches to a person who is already totally on fire. The choice, and ultimately, the amount of influence made on the individual, is in their own hands.
But I digress.
What tickles me more than anything about this whole ordeal, is that by thwarting the great evils of pop culture, they are in turn breeding their own. And while their ‘pop culture’ might be right for them, it may not be right for everybody else. If you disagree with the disturbing images on TV, turn it off. If the radio is blaring out swear words far too many times per song, change the station.
But the glossy, glamorous appeal of popular culture too often obscures that path to God, Teen Mania followers say.So, let me get this straight. To persuade people from the flash and glitter of ‘pop culture’, to clean up their path to God, you’re gonna hold rallies with hundreds of thousands of people, pass out merchandise, scream about a particular message and cheer along with your fans?Sounds a lot like a rock show, to me.
Also, I had to throw this in at the end, because I thought of it a bit late.
The BEATLES are too hardcore for you?
Are you SERIOUS?
September 17, 2007 at 8:06 pm
Why do you care what Christians are doing? If you think we should turn the radio if we don’t like what is playing, why are you going to talk about what we are doing? Don’t be hypocritical when you don’t even know what is going on.
September 18, 2007 at 1:45 pm
The thing is, in this particular case, I -do- know what’s going on. The internet has informed me. At least insomuch as this specific article has let on. I haven’t done any research into this movement to speculate past what information I had when I read this, but I’m pretty sure it’s lame either way. I’m not picking on Christians in particular here, because if anyone else had proclaimed me (i consider myself to be a product of pop culture) a ‘virtual terrorist’, I’d have pointed out their flaws in the same fashion.
The TV doesn’t beam things into your house directly targetted at you. The Radio isn’t so personalized as to claim to be playing songs you want to hear. The people in ‘Teen Mania’ have claimed that they are right and other people are wrong, I’m presenting the opposite side of things. Maybe they’re wrong, maybe not. I just throw it out there to read.
And I thank you for seeing this and responding, because it means people are actually paying attention to my writings.
September 18, 2007 at 6:10 pm
I really don’t understand all the arguments with Teen Mania. It really quite confuses me actually.
Aren’t there better things to do with your time than to argue against a man and his team trying to give youth something posative to do with there time.
I realize that everyone has the capability of turning off their radio or there television.
I also realize that these things DO impact teenagers negativley and that a child raised not exposed to these things WOULD act very differently.
You only focus on what you want to. If you really broke it down, and chunked this case up, all you would have is a ministry trying to show teenagers that there is more to life than sex, drugs, and money. Which you can’t argue that this is ALL most media displays. I listen to the radio and i watch television, i dont advise anyone under me to avoid these things…. what were trying to do is build enough into them where they can make good decisions that will impact them in a posative way, not trying to control them. Battling against or eliminating media is very little of what Teen Mania does.
Most of there time goes into impacting posatively teenagers. Showing them that it may be better to just turn it off. I just wish you and many others could fully understand what goes on at TeenMania. Deeply, not just at a weekend rally. There is so much more good things coming from this ministry. So please, please, think really hard about the things you put your time and energy against protesting, because i think you would find there are far more important ppl you could focus in on rather than TeenMania.
Thank you for your time,
have a blessed day.
– Mindy Peterson
October 3, 2007 at 1:50 am
I’m not ‘protesting’ against Teen Mania. I’m saying this specific thing is really, really dumb. As stated in my countercomment to Danielle, I only go with what I read. That might make me uninformed on the broad scope of things, but I’m not talking about the broad scope of things, I’m talking about what the article says. “We’re fighting for those who don’t know they have a voice..” or whatever. Basically, you’re giving them a voice, but making the words your own. I don’t like someone saying “I think you should have a choice” and in the same breath saying “and this is the one you should make.”
I’m seriously not trying to be a bad guy here, I’m trying to be realistic. Yes, kids not exposed to the violence, swearing, drug abuse, and subterfuge the media puts out will behave very differently than kids who are. But that isn’t always a good thing. Basically, it all comes down to the personal choices of the individual, and that’s where my problem lies. Those who want to live their lives for Jesus are at the rallies, they are making the decision to circumvent the evils of the media. Those who don’t see things in ‘pop culture’ as bad, aren’t going to care much about your message, whether it’s right or wrong, and won’t be going.
And I honestly don’t think thousands of people gathered together shouting about the horrible things pop culture does will stop it. It’s called popular for a reason, and until morality and decency become popular (I’d say again, but I don’t think they ever were), we’ll have to put up with it.